Could AI images make customers feel misled and damage my brand?
By Dan BartleyUpdated 4 minute read
The short answer
Yes, if the image shows something the customer does not receive, or looks so generated that the brand seems careless. AI imagery itself is not the risk: a styled room around an accurate product is no different from a set built for a shoot. The damage comes from inaccurate products, invented people and claims, and frames nobody checked before they went live.
When do customers feel misled by AI images?
When the product that arrives is not the one in the picture, or when they discover that something they took as real was invented. Both feel like being tricked, and both get talked about in reviews and comments.
- The colour, size, texture or finish is different in person
- The scene implied items were included that are not in the box
- A "customer photo", review or testimonial turns out to be generated
- A model in the ad looks like a real person who never agreed to it
- The product page described a generated room as a real home or a studio shoot
- The ad showed a result the product cannot deliver
How can an accurate AI image still hurt a brand?
By looking generated. Waxy surfaces, light that does not belong to the room, warped text in the background and a product that floats above the floor all make a store look careless, and scam stores have turned obvious AI images into a warning sign for many shoppers.
The fix is finish rather than avoidance. Every one of those faults can be corrected by hand: the contact shadow added, the light matched, the stray text removed, the texture restored.
Which uses of AI imagery carry the least brand risk?
The ones where AI only supplies the setting. Risk rises as the AI moves from the scene to the product, and again from the product to people.
| Use | Risk | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Room and lifestyle scenes around an accurate product | Low | The product is real; the room is context |
| Seasonal or campaign versions of existing frames | Low | Same product, new setting |
| Detail and close-up frames | Medium | Buyers use them to judge quality, so texture and finish must match exactly |
| Colourways made from one product | Medium | Each colour needs a real reference, or it is a guess |
| Generated models wearing or using the product | Higher | Fit has to be true, and the person must resemble no one real |
| Generated reviewers, customer photos or testimonials | Do not use | An invented testimonial misleads by design |
What do Australians say about brands that use AI in ads?
Many are sceptical. In a May 2026 YouGov survey of 1,046 Australians, 44% said they would be less likely to consider a brand that used mainly AI-generated advertising, and 48% said AI-generated ads make them feel uneasy or sceptical about the brand behind them.
Both questions were about advertising made mainly with AI, and both describe how people react to AI they notice. The reaction lands on the brand, not the tool, which is why accuracy and finish carry so much weight: they keep the frame about the product.
Where does a misleading image become a legal problem?
When the overall impression it gives a shopper is false. An image that misleads can breach the Australian Consumer Law or New Zealand's Fair Trading Act whatever the business intended, and a label saying it was made with AI does not cure it.
The detail, with the regulators' own guidance, is in is it legal to use AI-generated images of my product in Australia and NZ? Brand damage usually arrives first, through returns, reviews and comments, well before any regulator does.
How do I use AI imagery without damaging the brand?
Change the setting, never the product, and check every frame before it goes live. Use AI for the parts of a shoot that were only ever a setting, and treat the product as fixed.
- Keep the product exact: colour, size, materials, parts and every word of text
- Make clear what is included when the scene shows other items
- Never generate customers, reviews, testimonials or user content
- Never generate a person who resembles someone real
- Keep one look across the range, so the store looks like one brand
- Finish each frame until it holds up at full size
- Fix or replace any frame a customer questions
Other questions people ask about this
What should I say if a customer asks whether our photos are AI?
Answer plainly: the settings are made with AI from photos of the real product, and the product is shown as it is. Offer a phone photo of the product beside the frame if they want to compare.
Is it riskier to use AI models than AI rooms?
Generally, yes, because a person can be taken for a real customer or a real model in a way a room cannot. If you use generated people, make sure they resemble no one real and never present them as customers.
Read the full answerCan AI imagery work for a premium brand?
Yes, when it is finished to the same standard as everything else the brand puts out. Premium buyers zoom in, so texture, stitching and finish need to hold up at full size.
Should I stop using AI after a complaint?
Fix the cause first. If the complaint is about the product not matching the image, correct or replace that frame and check the rest of the set against the real product; if it is about how the scene looks, finish it properly.
Still have a question? Ask us